Yea sadly it's not hitting the bearing when the blade grip is on. I tried that out. I took the bearing out, put the arm on, and put the screw in. It doesn't even come close to hitting the inner part of the blade grip. It literally just pulled the upper half of the threads out.
Thanks for the input so far though. JB Weld is going to be my friend if I yet again strip the new one out some how. Otherwise I'm slapping red locktite in there and seeing how that works out.